Stanford gathers 52 causal studies on AI in schools and sees uneven results
The November review goes from 20 to 52 studies and concludes that AI looks more promising for understanding new material than for producing assignments, but no use improves learning consistently.
Stanford University’s SCALE initiative published “The Evidence Base on AI in K-12: A November 2026 Review” on 10 November 2026, an update of its March review. It includes only causal studies, that is, randomised trials and similar designs that make it possible to attribute an effect to AI. It goes from 20 to 52 studies, 32 of them new and published between October 2025 and June 2026. Five of the new ones, focused on students, were carried out in US schools, compared with none in the previous review.
According to the review, using AI to support learning looks more favourable than using it to do the assignments: in a study of university students in Brazil, producing the work with AI worsened performance in a later assessment without it. Even so, no type of use improves learning consistently, and students liking the experience does not always translate into better results.
Among the cases it cites is one in Turkey, with 193 teachers and 2,816 students from grades 5 to 12, in which giving teachers an AI assistant based on GPT-4o reduced students’ motivation and confidence; marks fell with teachers who had lower prior performance. Another, in Sierra Leone, with 1,423 mathematics students in grades 7 and 8, showed an improvement when teachers built Gemini Guided Learning, the guided-study mode of Google’s assistant, into half of their lessons; it is signed by a team from Google and Fab AI, and Google.org is among the funders of the review itself.
The authors themselves warn that the results cannot be generalised to the whole US school system, that the evidence on equity and long-term effects is scarce and that many studies are preprints, that is, papers circulated without peer review.
Stanford gathers 52 causal studies on AI in schools and sees uneven results
The November review goes from 20 to 52 studies and concludes that AI looks more promising for understanding new material than for producing assignments, but no use improves learning consistently.
Stanford University’s SCALE initiative published “The Evidence Base on AI in K-12: A November 2026 Review” on 10 November 2026, an update of its March review. It includes only causal studies, that is, randomised trials and similar designs that make it possible to attribute an effect to AI. It goes from 20 to 52 studies, 32 of them new and published between October 2025 and June 2026. Five of the new ones, focused on students, were carried out in US schools, compared with none in the previous review.
According to the review, using AI to support learning looks more favourable than using it to do the assignments: in a study of university students in Brazil, producing the work with AI worsened performance in a later assessment without it. Even so, no type of use improves learning consistently, and students liking the experience does not always translate into better results.
Among the cases it cites is one in Turkey, with 193 teachers and 2,816 students from grades 5 to 12, in which giving teachers an AI assistant based on GPT-4o reduced students’ motivation and confidence; marks fell with teachers who had lower prior performance. Another, in Sierra Leone, with 1,423 mathematics students in grades 7 and 8, showed an improvement when teachers built Gemini Guided Learning, the guided-study mode of Google’s assistant, into half of their lessons; it is signed by a team from Google and Fab AI, and Google.org is among the funders of the review itself.
The authors themselves warn that the results cannot be generalised to the whole US school system, that the evidence on equity and long-term effects is scarce and that many studies are preprints, that is, papers circulated without peer review.