A teacher reflective journal with AI raises the question of whether the assistant supports or replaces judgement
A master’s thesis project proposes dictating after each class and having an assistant organise the text and return questions; the group debates whether that weakens judgement.
A member of the group presented the Diario Reflexivo Docente (Teacher Reflective Journal), a free Notion template that, according to its author, is their master’s thesis project. The teacher dictates from their phone on leaving class and answers five questions: what happened, how they felt, why, what they took for granted and what they will change. An AI assistant organises the dictation, returns “the questions you hadn’t asked yourself” and proposes a weekly summary that the teacher accepts or not. The instructions are text, so they work with different assistants, and it can also be used without AI. The paper has not been able to check the template’s content, who is behind it or how it handles the data that is dictated, because the website does not say in what could be read.
One position holds that it is not very human and that critical thinking is being delegated, with a risk to the autonomy of the person reflecting. The other replies that the writing is the teacher’s, that the assistant acts as support and that each proposal must be validated, and that the danger of accepting everything without analysis depends on how each person uses it, not on the tool.
A teacher reflective journal with AI raises the question of whether the assistant supports or replaces judgement
A master’s thesis project proposes dictating after each class and having an assistant organise the text and return questions; the group debates whether that weakens judgement.
A member of the group presented the Diario Reflexivo Docente (Teacher Reflective Journal), a free Notion template that, according to its author, is their master’s thesis project. The teacher dictates from their phone on leaving class and answers five questions: what happened, how they felt, why, what they took for granted and what they will change. An AI assistant organises the dictation, returns “the questions you hadn’t asked yourself” and proposes a weekly summary that the teacher accepts or not. The instructions are text, so they work with different assistants, and it can also be used without AI. The paper has not been able to check the template’s content, who is behind it or how it handles the data that is dictated, because the website does not say in what could be read.
One position holds that it is not very human and that critical thinking is being delegated, with a risk to the autonomy of the person reflecting. The other replies that the writing is the teacher’s, that the assistant acts as support and that each proposal must be validated, and that the danger of accepting everything without analysis depends on how each person uses it, not on the tool.