Declaring AI use: a teacher asks schools to clarify which uses are acceptable
A teacher asks whether schools, very focused on detecting AI-generated work, explain clearly enough which uses are acceptable and how to declare them.
The usual debate in schools is how to detect work done with AI. In ChatGPT-IA-edu, a teacher proposed shifting it towards transparency of the process, based on “Verdad a medias: ¿hay que declarar cómo hemos utilizado la IA?” (“A half-truth: do we have to declare how we have used AI?”), an instalment of his series “Familias con inteligencia”. Its author is Chema Falcó, a secondary and sixth-form teacher; the paper has already reported on other instalments of the series, on homework done with AI and on the percentage given by a detector.
The instalment starts from two first-year Bachillerato students, Laura and Pablo, on a piece of work in which AI may be used if it is declared. Laura used it for ideas and to check requirements, but her report presents the work as individual; Pablo declared minimal use and later admitted that he had relied on it extensively. According to the author, the cases serve to work with students on academic integrity, authorship, responsibility and the traceability of learning, and he argues that declaring does not detract from merit but makes authorship verifiable. He proposes a three-sentence template (“I used AI to…”, “Afterwards I verified…”, “The research and the writing were mine”) and points to the INTEF guide, which includes a model declaration.
In the group, the author added the underlying question for schools and teachers: whether it is being explained clearly enough which uses are acceptable, which are not and how they should be declared. He is concerned, he said, that students who want to do the right thing perceive that declaring may count against them. The message ended by asking whether a declaration of AI use is required and of what kind; there is no record of the group replying that day.
The same idea of declaring permitted uses and asking for evidence of the process is the one put forward in Sunday’s feature on AI detectors.
Declaring AI use: a teacher asks schools to clarify which uses are acceptable
A teacher asks whether schools, very focused on detecting AI-generated work, explain clearly enough which uses are acceptable and how to declare them.
The usual debate in schools is how to detect work done with AI. In ChatGPT-IA-edu, a teacher proposed shifting it towards transparency of the process, based on “Verdad a medias: ¿hay que declarar cómo hemos utilizado la IA?” (“A half-truth: do we have to declare how we have used AI?”), an instalment of his series “Familias con inteligencia”. Its author is Chema Falcó, a secondary and sixth-form teacher; the paper has already reported on other instalments of the series, on homework done with AI and on the percentage given by a detector.
The instalment starts from two first-year Bachillerato students, Laura and Pablo, on a piece of work in which AI may be used if it is declared. Laura used it for ideas and to check requirements, but her report presents the work as individual; Pablo declared minimal use and later admitted that he had relied on it extensively. According to the author, the cases serve to work with students on academic integrity, authorship, responsibility and the traceability of learning, and he argues that declaring does not detract from merit but makes authorship verifiable. He proposes a three-sentence template (“I used AI to…”, “Afterwards I verified…”, “The research and the writing were mine”) and points to the INTEF guide, which includes a model declaration.
In the group, the author added the underlying question for schools and teachers: whether it is being explained clearly enough which uses are acceptable, which are not and how they should be declared. He is concerned, he said, that students who want to do the right thing perceive that declaring may count against them. The message ended by asking whether a declaration of AI use is required and of what kind; there is no record of the group replying that day.
The same idea of declaring permitted uses and asking for evidence of the process is the one put forward in Sunday’s feature on AI detectors.